An Unowned Line Item: Allocating Scaffold Security Costs in UK Construction Contracts
Photo: construction contract documents and hard hat on desk UK quantity surveying, via www.cfisherconstruction.com
The quietest deletion on the project
Ask why a scaffold alarm was omitted and the answer is seldom a considered acceptance of risk. More often the item never had an owner. It sat in a tender return as an unpriced assumption, was absorbed into a preliminaries figure nobody could unpick, and disappeared at the first value-engineering session because it was the only line that no one at the table was accountable for defending.
The consequence is familiar: a scaffold stands for eleven weeks, the site is burgled in week four, and the post-incident conversation turns on whose obligation it was. The contract, in most cases, is silent.
Where the money actually goes
The erosion typically happens in three places. At tender, where contractors price what the employer's requirements describe and nothing else. At pre-start, where the principal contractor assumes the scaffolder is providing detection because the scaffold is theirs. And at handover, where the temporary works are struck before anyone has established whether the security installed was ever designed, commissioned or recorded.
Each of these is a contract problem before it is a technical one.
JCT: the provisional sum route
Under the JCT 2024 family, the cleanest mechanism is a provisional sum carried in the employer's requirements or the specification, expended on the architect or contract administrator's instruction. That does three things: it puts the line in the tender documents so it cannot be quietly assumed away, it requires an instruction before money is spent, and it leaves a written record of the decision if the employer chooses not to spend it.
A defined provisional sum, tied to a described scope, is preferable to an undefined sum, which invites a contractor to make allowances at its own discretion. Either way, the description should specify the outcome — detection coverage, logging, response arrangements — rather than a quantity of hardware.
NEC4: scope, not goodwill
NEC4 contracts work differently. The protection comes from the Scope: if temporary security appears in the Scope with a performance specification, the Contractor is obliged to provide it, and any subsequent reduction is a change to the Scope and therefore a compensation event. That is a far stronger position than a note in the Contractor's tender.
The Activity Schedule is where the cost becomes visible. A named activity item for scaffold detection, commissioning and dismantling gives the Project Manager something to assess progress against, and gives the Contractor a defensible cost line when the Works Information changes.
CDM 2015: coordination is a duty
The Construction (Design and Management) Regulations 2015 place the duty to coordinate temporary works — including temporary security — with parties who often treat it as an administrative courtesy. The client must make suitable arrangements for managing the project, including the allocation of time and resource. The principal contractor must plan, manage and monitor the construction phase. A security provision that falls between the scaffolder's scope, the principal contractor's preliminaries and the client's insurance requirements has not been coordinated; it has been dispersed.
Projects within the scope of the Building Safety Act 2022 raise the stakes further, because the quality of recorded decisions about temporary works on higher-risk buildings becomes part of the golden thread rather than a site note.
‘By others’ is not a control
The phrase does more damage than any other three words in a specification. It records that someone else is responsible while leaving the identity, scope, timing and evidence requirements undefined. If the answer to ‘who is installing detection?’ is ‘by others’, the honest translation is ‘nobody has checked’.
Wording that can be put in front of a client
The following are drafting prompts for discussion with a contract professional, not a substitute for advice.
JCT — specification/provisional sum. Allow a defined provisional sum for the design, installation, commissioning, maintenance and removal of a scaffold-mounted intruder detection system covering the elevations described, installed by a specialist contractor, commissioned with a recorded walk test, and handed over with an as-installed drawing, zone schedule, commissioning certificate and response plan.
NEC4 — Scope. The Contractor is to provide temporary intruder detection to the scaffold and associated compounds, achieving detection of approach and entry as described, with event logging retained for the construction phase and a documented response protocol. The Activity Schedule is to include a separate activity for installation and commissioning.
Evidence at completion. The Contractor is to provide, before striking of the scaffold, a handover file comprising as-installed drawings, zone and device schedules, commissioning records, isolation log, and a statement of any zones that were masked and why.
Change control. Any reduction in the specified coverage requires written instruction and is to be recorded in the site security log with the reason and the residual risk accepted.
What good looks like
The test is simple: at the end of the job, could a third party read the contract and the handover file and establish exactly what was installed, who paid for it, and who was responsible for it on each date? If the answer is no, the project has not allocated the cost — it has deferred the argument to a date when nobody remembers the site.
Security is not a courtesy that emerges from good relations between trades. It is a line item with a name against it.